This is completely unrelated to the premise of the blog but I'm posting it anyway because the Yankees are so great.
Here are some stats for you to chew on as you ponder how it is possible that the “experts” are wrong in predicting the outcome of the Yankees vs. Cleveland.
Game 1
C.C. Sabathia - Lefty
Career versus the Yankees in 8 starts is 1-7 with a 7.13 ERA and a whopping WHIP (walks plus hits per innings pitched) of 1.75 (meaning that he allows close to 2 base runners per inning, not good). Of course pundits will point to the fact that he had not faced the Yankees since 2004 and that his Cy Young caliber season this year (19-7, 3.21 ERA, 1.14 WHIP) makes him a completely different pitcher. I beg to differ as C.C will always be C.C. For proof, I can point to his other great season in 2002 where he went 13-9 with a 3.60 ERA and a 1.30 WHIP. In that season, the Yankees crushed him in his 2 games started and he went an ugly 0-2 with a 5.54 ERA with a 1.38 WHIP.
As for the Yankees hitters faring against this lefty, it is safe to say that A-Rod and Jeter will utterly destroy him as they have gone 474 and 583 OBP respectively in their lifetime. The only worry for the rest of the Yankees lineup is Damon and Abreu who really stinks against Lefty. This is more than countered by Posada, Cano, and Matsui who can hit lefty pitchers just as well as righty. The X factor in all this is Shelley Duncan who hits big (303 BA) against lefty pitching this season.
Conclusion: CC will lose game 1 yielding 5-6 runs although he will keep Cleveland in the game for a while.
Game 2
Fausto Carmona – Righty
Here is the fabulous sophomore pitcher that all the “experts” rave about in the Cleveland lineup. What these “experts” don’t know his that this guy sucks against the potent Yankee lineup. In the 2 games against the Yanks this season, he sports a mediocre ERA of 4.15 but this is a false statistic as he allows the Yanks to hit 292 off of him.
For the Yankee hitters, the reverse of CC holds true as all the lefty does phenomenal against him including Damon and Abreu with A-Rod stinking. Jeter though hits a robust 429 while getting on base 50% of the time.
The only positive for Carmona is that post All-Star he was nothing short of Cy Young like including an exclamation point of going 5-0 with a 1.78 ERA and a whimsy 0.99 WHIP in September. Of course this is all tempered by his other volatile months preceding it.
June: 5.82 ERA 1.50 WHIP
July: 1.74 ERA 1.09 WHIP
August 3.43 ERA 1.24 WHIP
Sep 1.78 ERA 0.99 WHIP
Notice the whipsaw up and downs in ERA and more importantly, WHIP. Seeing how this pattern would unfold, I sense that October would yield a bad month for him and greatness for the Yankees. I’m personally hoping for a repeat of his marvelous June performance.
Conclusion: Fausto will allow at least 5 runs as the heavy lefty hitting Yankee lineup will get to him as well as his see saw pitching history and he will lose the game.
Game 3
Jake “the castoff” Westbrook – Righty
Ah yes, Yankee castoffs. Of all the ones the Yankees had let go, which includes a nice lineup of Eric Milton, Ted Lilly, and Javier Vazquez, it is safe to say that none of them had much affect on the Yanks in the postseason (only exception is Kenny Rogers which is perhaps due to the steroids he is taking that is currently unknown to the press and MLB). Once a castoff, always a castoff, as they would never be good or why else would the Yankees let them go.
The story on Westbrook is pretty much the same as Fausto as lefty hitterse had feasted on him throughout the season. Yankee righties including A-Rod and Jeter also had success with him batting over 300. Coupled our tremendous hitting with the legendary heckling of Yankee castoffs and it is safe to say that Westbrook will falter … horribly.
Conclusion: Yanks will score at least 8 runs and blow out Cleveland.
I haven’t even gone into how horrendous their closer is (blowing the most saves in the regular season and close to singlehandedly killing my fantasy baseball team) so this only goes to prove that even if their starters last, their bullpen will give it right back up.
I smell a SWEEP. As they say, you could take the regular season away from the Indians (96-66 tied for best in MLB) but you can’t take the Indians away from being the Indians (0 championships in the modern era including the big choke in the 1997 WS).
-Myth
Note: My predictions are based on complete, unbiased, statistic backed proof on the greatness of the Yankees which does not include the aging starting lineup and the fragile bullpen aside from Joba so you can take it with confidence.